There is no single better surfacing option for every playground. The right choice depends on your budget, maintenance needs, accessibility goals and design preferences.
Poured-in-place (PIP) surfacing is a unitary EPDM system with a higher initial cost, low maintenance requirements and strong accessibility for people who use wheelchairs and other mobility devices. Because it is poured on-site, PIP also allows for more custom color blends, patterns and graphics.
Loose rubber mulch has a lower initial cost and offers a more traditional, natural appearance similar to wood mulch. However, because it is a loose-fill material, it requires ongoing maintenance, such as raking and redistributing material, to help maintain proper depth and coverage. Bonded rubber mulch differs from loose rubber mulch in that it forms a single surface. It typically costs more than loose-fill rubber mulch but requires less ongoing maintenance and provides better accessibility for people who use mobility devices.
For playgrounds that need a highly accessible, low-maintenance surface with extensive design flexibility, PIP is often the stronger choice. For projects prioritizing a lower initial cost or a natural look, loose rubber mulch may be a better fit.